top of page

Back to the Office: What Employers May Order

Nov 10
3 min read

Ending home office, introducing an on-site requirement, designing compensation – the legal position for employers

According to media reports, a bank is compensating for the lack of home office options by granting additional days of leave. Many companies are concerned with the opposite question: how can they bring employees back to the office in a legally secure manner? What is decisive is the basis on which home office has been granted so far.

Starting point: the right to give instructions

Under § 106 sentence 1 GewO (Trade Code), the employer may specify in more detail “the content, place and time of the work” at its reasonable discretion (billiges Ermessen), insofar as the employment contract, a works agreement, a collective agreement or statute does not lay anything down. There is no general statutory entitlement to home office. Where the place of work is left open in the contract and home office was merely permitted, the employer can in principle withdraw the permission. The Munich Higher Labour Court (LAG) confirmed this in summary proceedings because, in the specific case, operational reasons stood in the way (judgment of 26.08.2021 – 3 SaGa 13/21).

Reasonable discretion: document the reasons

The withdrawal must accord with reasonable discretion, that is, it must appropriately balance the interests of both sides. The employer must set out and prove this. The Cologne Higher Labour Court held the withdrawal of home office, combined with a transfer to a site some 500 km away, to be ineffective; the employee had worked mainly from home for years, and it remained unclear which tasks required presence (judgment of 11.07.2024 – 6 Sa 579/23). At first instance, the Labour Court of Düsseldorf rejected an on-site requirement on four weekdays because the employer failed to explain comprehensibly how presence would solve the alleged communication and performance problems; at the same time, it dismissed a claim to 50 per cent home office (judgment of 11.02.2026 – 3 Ca 6587/25). General references to communication or supervision are therefore not sufficient.

Contract, promise or works agreement?

Where home office is firmly agreed in the employment contract, the right to give instructions does not help. What remains is a change by mutual agreement or a termination for the purpose of changing the terms of employment (Änderungskündigung), which, within the scope of the Protection Against Dismissal Act, must be socially justified. A reservation of the right to revoke in pre-formulated contracts must be reasonable for the employee (§ 308 no. 4 BGB, German Civil Code); the grounds for revocation should be stated in the clause. Where home office is regulated in a works agreement, it can, unless otherwise agreed, be terminated on three months' notice (§ 77 para. 5 BetrVG, Works Constitution Act). Continued effect (Nachwirkung) under § 77 para. 6 BetrVG comes into consideration only for rules subject to co-determination on the design of such work.

The role of the works council

The works council has a right of co-determination on the “design of mobile work” that is performed by means of information and communication technology (§ 87 para. 1 no. 14 BetrVG), that is, on the how – for example scope and times. Whether mobile work is offered at all is, in the prevailing view, decided by the employer. Where rules on order in the establishment change, § 87 para. 1 no. 1 BetrVG may be affected.

Compensation for on-site staff: additional leave

Beyond the statutory minimum leave of 24 working days (Werktage; § 3 para. 1 BUrlG, Federal Leave Act; 20 working days on a five-day week), employers may grant leave voluntarily. Anyone who differentiates between groups is bound by the principle of equal treatment under employment law. For special payments, the Federal Labour Court has recognised the compensation of different working conditions as an objective reason, provided it does not overcompensate (judgment of 13.04.2011 – 10 AZR 88/10); the same should apply to additional leave. Purpose and conditions should be set down in writing. Co-determination by the works council must be examined in the individual case.

Checklist for companies

  • Clarify the legal basis: contract, promise, works agreement or mere permission

  • Document concrete reasons for presence for each function

  • Weigh personal circumstances and provide transition periods

  • Involve the works council early

  • Regulate compensation benefits with a clear purpose

  • Design future home office arrangements as a revocable permission with stated grounds for revocation

Conclusion

A return to the office is often permissible, but it is not automatic. Those who examine the legal basis and document their reasons in a comprehensible manner reduce the litigation risk.


As of: 10.11.2026

NIETZER Rechtsanwälte · Attorneys at Law (USA) · Heilbronn · www.unternehmensrecht.com

This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace legal advice in an individual case.

Recent Posts

See All
bottom of page