Buying from Insolvency: What Transfers – and What Does Not
Acquiring a business out of insolvency – asset deal, liability for historical debts and transfer of undertakings at a glance
According to media reports, the search for investors has begun following the renewed insolvency filing of a nationally known department store chain; the preliminary insolvency administrator intends to review the locations individually. Such proceedings give competitors, financial investors and medium-sized companies the opportunity to take over businesses or parts of businesses. However, an acquisition out of insolvency follows its own rules.
Asset Deal Instead of a Share Purchase
The usual route is the so-called transfer restructuring (übertragende Sanierung): the buyer does not acquire the company itself (share deal) but individual assets such as machinery, inventory, trademarks or customer data (asset deal). The debts in principle remain with the insolvent entity; exceptions are explained below. Each asset must be described precisely in the purchase agreement. Contracts with customers, suppliers or landlords do not pass automatically; the buyer needs the consent of the respective counterparty. Employment relationships are different (see below). In the case of customer data, data protection must also be taken into account.
Who Decides on the Seller’s Side
After the opening of proceedings, the insolvency administrator sells; in self-administration (Eigenverwaltung), the debtor itself sells under the supervision of a custodian (Sachwalter). To sell the company or a business, the administrator needs the consent of the creditors’ committee or, if none has been appointed, of the creditors’ meeting (§ 160 InsO). If the buyer is close to the debtor – for example as a former shareholder – or is a creditor holding at least one fifth of the volume of claims and security rights, the creditors’ meeting must consent; this also applies if such a person holds at least one fifth of the buyer (§ 162 InsO). If consent is missing, the purchase agreement nevertheless remains effective vis-à-vis third parties (§ 164 InsO). The administrator generally gives warranties only to a very limited extent. A careful due diligence of one’s own is therefore all the more important.
No Liability for Historical Debts – on Acquisition After Opening
Anyone who continues a commercial business under the previous firm name is in principle liable for its historical liabilities (§ 25 Abs. 1 Satz 1 HGB). On an acquisition from the insolvency administrator in opened proceedings, this does not apply according to settled case law. The Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof) has extended this to a sale by the debtor in self-administration (BGH, judgment of 3 December 2019 – II ZR 457/18). In an out-of-court restructuring, by contrast, this relief does not apply. Buyers should clarify tax liability issues with their tax adviser.
Employees Transfer Too
Section 613a BGB also applies in insolvency: where a business or part of a business is transferred, the acquirer takes over the existing employment relationships. A dismissal because of the transfer of the business is invalid; for other reasons it remains possible. The employees must be informed in advance in text form and may object to the transfer within one month. According to the case law of the Federal Labour Court (Bundesarbeitsgericht), the acquirer is in principle not liable for claims from the period before the opening of proceedings; in the case of company pensions it bears only the part earned after the opening (BAG, judgment of 26 January 2021 – 3 AZR 139/17). If the buyer takes over the business before the opening, this privilege does not apply. The administrator can prepare any necessary reduction of staff with the works council by way of a reconciliation of interests with a list of names (Interessenausgleich mit Namensliste), even if the measure is based on the acquirer’s concept and is implemented only after the sale (§ 128 InsO).
Timing Is Decisive
The liability relief is tied to the opening of proceedings. If completion takes place in the preliminary proceedings, there is a risk of liability for continuing the firm name, full liability for employee claims and, under certain circumstances, insolvency avoidance. In practice, the purchase agreement is therefore often negotiated in the preliminary proceedings but completed only on or after the opening.
Checklist for Buyers
Clarify the stage of the proceedings: preliminary or opened proceedings, regular proceedings or self-administration.
List the assets to be purchased completely and unambiguously (inventory, intellectual property rights, data).
Check third-party rights, such as retention of title and security transfers of ownership.
Agree the consent of the creditors’ bodies as a condition to completion.
Negotiate key contracts (lease, licences, major customers) with the counterparties at an early stage.
Prepare the information of the employees carefully together with the administrator.
Include company pensions and works council structures in the planning.
Conclusion
Buying out of insolvency can make it possible to acquire a business without historical debts – provided that timing, contract design and consequences under employment law are carefully planned. Please do not hesitate to contact us if you have any questions.
Status: 17 October 2026
NIETZER Rechtsanwälte · Attorneys at Law (USA) · Heilbronn · www.unternehmensrecht.com
This article is for general information purposes and does not replace legal advice in an individual case.

