top of page

GmbH Law Update: Failure to Invite a Shareholder Can Void Resolutions

4 days ago
2 min read

News from the Federal Court of Justice on the shareholders’ meeting – and what is known about the planned “company with tied assets”

Anyone who manages or holds shares in a GmbH (German limited liability company) usually takes decisions in the shareholders’ meeting. Defects in the invitation quickly affect the validity of resolutions. The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) reaffirmed this in May 2026. At the same time, the federal government is working on a new legal form for companies with tied assets.

Invitation defects lead to nullity

All shareholders listed in the shareholder list filed with the commercial register must be invited to the meeting (Section 51(1) GmbHG). Vis-à-vis the company, whoever is entered in this list is deemed a shareholder (Section 16(1) sentence 1 GmbHG). This applies irrespective of who actually owns the share.

In its judgment of 5 May 2026 (II ZR 2/25), the BGH held: if a shareholder entered in the list is not invited, the resolutions passed there are void under settled case law (Section 241 no. 1 AktG, applied by analogy). The fact that the managing director of the uninvited shareholder knew of the meeting changes nothing, because every shareholder must be invited individually. An invitation to one company does not replace the invitation to another, even if the same person represents both.

Consequences for contracts with shareholders

The case was explosive because, on the basis of the void resolution, the company had concluded a financing agreement with a company controlled by a shareholder. According to available reports, the BGH regarded the agreement as provisionally ineffective because the shareholder approval required under the articles of association was missing. A managing director’s authority to represent the company is generally not restrictable vis-à-vis third parties (Section 37(2) GmbHG); according to the reports, however, this protection does not apply to transactions with shareholders.

Outlook: company with tied assets

According to reports, the Federal Ministry of Finance and the Federal Ministry of Justice presented a framework concept on 4 March 2026 for a new legal form, the “company with tied assets” (Gesellschaft mit gebundenem Vermögen). Assets are to remain permanently in the company, profit distributions are to be excluded, and membership is to be non-transferable and non-heritable. To our knowledge, no draft bill exists; key questions remain open.

Practical checklist

  • Check the shareholder list at the commercial register before every invitation.

  • Invite every listed shareholder individually and verifiably.

  • Check the articles of association for approval requirements for transactions with shareholders.

  • If the validity of a resolution is in doubt, obtain legal advice early and, where appropriate, repeat the resolution.

  • Monitor the planned legal form for steward-ownership.

Conclusion

A careful invitation is not a formality but a condition of valid resolutions. Anyone who keeps an eye on the shareholder list avoids disputes and ineffective contracts. Please contact us if you have any questions.


As of: 18.11.2026

NIETZER Rechtsanwälte · Attorneys at Law (USA) · Heilbronn · www.unternehmensrecht.com

This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace legal advice in an individual case.

bottom of page