Internal Investigation at the U.S. Subsidiary: Who Investigates?
Misconduct by management in the U.S.: how German parent companies set up an internal investigation in a structured way
According to media reports, a U.S. technology group has launched an internal investigation into allegations against its CEO; it is being conducted by members of the Board of Directors together with external investigators. The question behind it also arises in the Mittelstand: what should be done when allegations are directed at the top management of one's own U.S. subsidiary?
The board is responsible, not the person concerned
In a corporation organised under Delaware law, the business and affairs are managed “by or under the direction of a board of directors” (8 Del. C. § 141(a)). The board may form committees consisting of one or more directors (§ 141(c)(2)). Where allegations are directed at the CEO or President, the investigation should therefore be placed with directors who are not themselves affected. The appointment and term of office of the officers (the executive officers of the company) are governed by the bylaws or by resolutions of the board (§ 142(b)). Interim measures such as suspension are decided by the board in accordance with the bylaws and the employment agreement.
Do not ignore warning signs
The Delaware Court of Chancery has held that not only directors but also officers owe a duty of oversight: within their area of responsibility they must ensure adequate channels of information and respond to warning signs (“red flags”) (In re McDonald's Corp. Stockholder Derivative Litigation, decision of 26.01.2023, C.A. No. 2021-0324-JTL). Liability, however, requires bad faith, for example the conscious disregard of red flags. The court also considered the personal harassing conduct of the head of human resources concerned to be a possible breach of the duty of loyalty. The decision was made on a motion to dismiss, that is, on the basis of the allegations in the complaint. For an LLC the following applies: the LLC agreement may expand, restrict or eliminate fiduciary duties; the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, however, remains in place (6 Del. C. § 18-1101(c)).
Secure confidentiality through counsel
In U.S. federal courts, the attorney-client privilege also protects reports by employees that are made to company counsel, at the direction of company management, in order to obtain legal advice (Upjohn Co. v. United States, 449 U.S. 383, 1981). What is protected is the communication, not the underlying facts; the state courts apply their own rules. Interviews should therefore be conducted by attorneys. In practice, they inform interviewees that they represent the company and not the employee (the “Upjohn warning”).
Preserve evidence
Where litigation is foreseeable, relevant electronic data must be preserved. If it is lost because reasonable preservation steps were not taken and it cannot be replaced, a U.S. federal court may, where the other side is prejudiced, order measures to cure the prejudice; where there was an intent to deprive the other side of the data, up to adverse inferences, dismissal or default judgment (Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 37(e)). A written preservation notice (litigation hold) should therefore come at the very beginning.
Practical checklist
Appoint disinterested directors or a committee.
Retain external U.S. counsel in order to secure the privilege.
Issue a litigation hold, also to the parent company where data is held there.
Review the bylaws, employment agreement and indemnification rules; inform the D&O insurer.
Observe data protection requirements where data from the EU is included.
Coordinate communications to employees, banks and authorities.
Conclusion
An internal investigation at the U.S. subsidiary requires clear responsibility, leadership by counsel and early preservation of evidence. Those who set these course early create good conditions for an orderly process. Please contact us if you have any questions.
As of: 09.11.2026
NIETZER Rechtsanwälte · Attorneys at Law (USA) · Heilbronn · www.unternehmensrecht.com
This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace legal advice in an individual case.

