top of page

Price Adjustment in Supply Contracts: What Is Valid

Nov 10
4 min read

Price adjustment clauses, index-linked price clauses, cost-element clauses: what applies between businesses

According to the Federal Statistical Office (Statistisches Bundesamt), the inflation rate in Germany was 3.3 per cent in September 2026 – the highest figure since December 2023. It was driven mainly by fuel and heating oil prices. For suppliers under long-term contracts the question arises whether they may pass on higher costs – and for buyers whether they have to accept this.

Basic Principle: A Deal Is a Deal

If a fixed price has been agreed, neither side can change it unilaterally. Rising purchasing or energy costs are then, in principle, borne by the supplier. A price increase therefore as a rule requires a contractual basis – a price adjustment clause (Preisanpassungsklausel).

Which Clauses the Price Clause Act Permits

The Price Clause Act (Preisklauselgesetz, PrKG) prohibits linking monetary debts directly and automatically to the price of goods that are not comparable with the agreed performance (§ 1 Abs. 1 PrKG). The following in particular remain permitted (§ 1 Abs. 2 PrKG):

  • Reservation-of-adjustment clauses (Leistungsvorbehaltsklauseln): the new price is determined on an equitable basis; a margin of discretion remains.

  • Tension clauses (Spannungsklauseln): the price follows a similar or comparable good.

  • Cost-element clauses (Kostenelementeklauseln): the price changes only to the extent that specific costs – for example for energy or raw materials – directly affect the supplier’s own costs (Selbstkosten).

A mere infringement of the PrKG takes effect only upon a final judicial determination (§ 8 PrKG). For clauses in standard terms, however, a stricter standard applies in addition.

Review of Standard Terms Also Between Businesses

Price adjustment clauses are usually contained in general terms and conditions (Allgemeine Geschäftsbedingungen, AGB), that is, pre-formulated contract terms. Even towards businesses they are invalid if they place the contracting party at an unreasonable disadvantage or are not clear and comprehensible (§ 307 Abs. 1 BGB in conjunction with § 310 Abs. 1 BGB).

In 2026 the Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof, BGH) clarified that such clauses are always subject to this review of standard terms in addition to the PrKG. If a clause does not withstand it, it is invalid from the outset; § 8 PrKG does not help then (BGH, judgment of 11.03.2026 – XII ZR 51/25). In that case the buyer can in principle reclaim amounts overpaid.

At the same time the BGH leaves scope in business dealings: a clause linking the working price (Arbeitspreis) of a natural gas contract to the heating oil price withstood review; whether the link is appropriate is a commercial decision of the customer (BGH, judgment of 14.05.2014 – VIII ZR 116/13). Courts therefore review the adjustment rule, not the agreed starting price.

From a drafting perspective, a clause is advisable that discloses the cost elements, their share in the price and the reference value (for example an official index), gives the supplier no additional profit, and takes cost reductions into account as well as cost increases.

Unilateral Right of Determination

If the supplier may fix the price itself, it must in case of doubt do so at its reasonable discretion (billiges Ermessen). If the determination is inequitable, it is not binding on the buyer; the court then decides (§ 315 Abs. 1 and 3 BGB). If the right of determination is contained in standard terms, it must in addition pass the review of standard terms.

Without a Clause: Disruption of the Basis of the Transaction as an Exception

Without a clause, only disruption of the basis of the transaction (Störung der Geschäftsgrundlage, § 313 BGB) remains. It requires a serious change of the circumstances forming the basis of the contract; the parties would not have concluded the contract in that form had they known of the change; and adherence to the contract must be unreasonable (unzumutbar). The contractual and statutory allocation of risk must expressly be taken into account – with a fixed price, the cost risk typically lies with the supplier. The primary legal consequence is an adjustment of the contract, otherwise withdrawal or, for continuing obligations, termination.

Practical Checklist for Businesses

  • Review existing supply and purchase contracts for price clauses.

  • Determine the type of clause and measure it against the PrKG and the law on standard terms.

  • Name cost elements, weighting and index transparently; provide for adjustment in both directions.

  • Negotiate the clause individually where possible and document the negotiation.

  • Where both sides use standard terms, check whether the price clause has become part of the contract at all.

  • As a buyer, do not accept price increases unchecked, but request the basis and the calculation.

Conclusion

Cost increases can be passed on only if the contract permits it and the clause is transparent and balanced. Anyone concluding or renewing contracts now should deliberately design the price provision. Please do not hesitate to contact us if you have any questions.

Status: 18 October 2026

NIETZER Rechtsanwälte · Attorneys at Law (USA) · Heilbronn · www.unternehmensrecht.com

This article is for general information purposes and does not replace legal advice in an individual case.

bottom of page