Cloud Outage: Who Is Liable When Nothing Works?
Cloud outage, SLA and SaaS contract: which claims companies have – and where they end
According to media reports, widely used cloud-based office services – e-mail, video conferencing, calendars – were disrupted worldwide last week, in part for more than 24 hours. Many companies could work only to a limited extent. We show which claims exist in the event of a cloud outage and where the limits lie.
Which contract applies?
With Software as a Service (SaaS), a company uses software that runs on the provider’s servers over the internet. The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) has classified such a contract as a lease (BGH, judgment of 15 November 2006 – XII ZR 120/04). By contrast, it has treated a streaming contract as a service contract, because the provider’s ongoing performance is paramount there (BGH, judgment of 16 April 2026 – III ZR 152/25). For SaaS, the focus of the individual contract therefore matters; lease law is predominantly applied.
Rent reduction and damages under lease law
If the software cannot be used for its contractual purpose, there is a defect. For the duration of the outage, the fee is reduced by operation of law, and in the case of a complete outage it lapses; insignificant impairments do not count (Section 536(1) BGB). Damages – for example for additional costs – are available above all where the provider is responsible for the defect (Section 536a(1) BGB). Outside residential tenancies, the reduction can be restricted by contract; in standard terms this is possible only to a limited extent.
What SLAs and standard terms make of it
In practice, the contract terms determine the outcome. Service level agreements (SLAs, i.e. promised availability levels) usually provide for credits where the level is not met. These are often intended to be the sole remedy; liability caps sit alongside them.
Between businesses, the validity of such standard terms and conditions is governed by Section 307 BGB. The prohibitions of clauses applicable to consumer contracts do not apply directly (Section 310(1) BGB) but have indicative effect. A complete exclusion of liability for gross negligence is therefore also invalid in business dealings; liability for duties that make performance of the contract possible in the first place must not be hollowed out (BGH, judgment of 19 September 2007 – VIII ZR 141/06). Availability is likely to be among these duties in the case of SaaS. Whether credits are effective as the sole remedy has not been conclusively settled.
Contracts of international providers also frequently contain a choice of law. It is generally effective (Article 3(1) Rome I Regulation); German standard-terms standards then do not necessarily apply.
The company’s own duties
Under Article 32(1) GDPR, companies must take measures appropriate to the risk to ensure the availability of their systems and to restore personal data swiftly after an incident. For important and particularly important entities, the new Act on the Federal Office for Information Security (BSIG), in force since 6 December 2025, expressly requires measures for business continuity, backup and crisis management and for supply chain security (Section 30(2) BSIG). Management must implement and oversee these measures (Section 38(1) BSIG).
Practical checklist
Review contracts: choice of law, SLA values, measurement method, credits, liability caps.
In the event of an outage: document start, duration and affected services; notify the defect without delay.
Claim credits within the applicable deadline.
Substantiate losses: downtime, additional costs.
Contingency plan: alternative communication channels, own data backup, responsibilities.
Conclusion
In the event of a cloud outage, statutory claims exist, the scope of which is usually determined by the contract. Anyone who knows their contracts and prepares in advance limits the damage. Please contact us if you have any questions.
As of: 17.11.2026
NIETZER Rechtsanwälte · Attorneys at Law (USA) · Heilbronn · www.unternehmensrecht.com
This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace legal advice in an individual case.


