top of page

Commercial Tenant Insolvent: Which Rights Landlords Keep

Nov 15
3 min read

Insolvency of the tenant in commercial leases: bar on termination, special termination right and landlord’s lien

According to media reports, a retail chain filed for insolvency again at the beginning of October 2026; rent is said to have been paid late even before that. Whether all locations will be retained is uncertain. For landlords of commercial premises this raises a typical question: what rights remain if the tenant becomes insolvent?

Bar on Termination from the Filing Onwards

After the application for the opening of insolvency proceedings has been filed, the landlord may no longer terminate “because of a default in the payment of rent or lease payments that occurred before the application for the opening of proceedings”, nor because of a deterioration in the tenant’s financial circumstances (§ 112 InsO). A termination validly declared before the filing, by contrast, remains effective. If rent falling due after the filing is not paid, the bar does not, according to its wording, cover this new default.

In the prevailing view, clauses that give the landlord a right of termination solely because of the insolvency filing do not help: agreements that exclude or restrict in advance the application of §§ 103 to 118 InsO are invalid (§ 119 InsO).

The Contract Continues – with Two Classes of Claims

Leases of premises continue after the opening of proceedings (§ 108 Abs. 1 InsO). What matters is the separation in time: claims for the period before the opening are ordinary insolvency claims (§ 108 Abs. 3 InsO). After the opening they are filed in the insolvency table (the court’s register of claims) and are usually satisfied only with a quota. Rent for the period after the opening constitutes estate liabilities (Masseverbindlichkeiten, § 55 Abs. 1 Nr. 2 InsO). It is paid ahead of the insolvency claims, provided the estate is sufficient.

For the phase between the filing and the opening, the rule is: as a general rule, this rent too remains an ordinary insolvency claim. It takes priority only if a preliminary administrator with power of disposal uses the premises (§ 55 Abs. 2 InsO) or if, in self-administration, the court authorises the debtor to create estate liabilities (§ 270c Abs. 4 InsO).

Special Termination Right After the Opening of Proceedings

From the opening of proceedings, the insolvency administrator may terminate the lease irrespective of any fixed term or exclusion of ordinary termination, with a notice period of three months to the end of a month, unless a shorter period applies (§ 109 Abs. 1 InsO). The landlord can claim damages for the premature termination only as an insolvency creditor. In self-administration, the debtor’s management exercises this right itself; it is to coordinate with the custodian (Sachwalter), a supervisory person appointed by the court (§ 279 InsO). Long lease terms therefore offer only limited security in the event of the tenant’s insolvency.

Landlord’s Lien as Security

The landlord has a lien on the tenant’s items brought onto the premises for its claims (§ 562 BGB, applicable to commercial premises via § 578 BGB). It covers only items owned by the tenant, so, for example, not goods that a supplier has sold under retention of title. In insolvency it entitles the landlord to separate, that is, preferential, satisfaction from the proceeds. This does not apply to rent that is older than twelve months before the opening, nor to damages for termination under § 109 InsO (§ 50 Abs. 2 InsO). If items are removed from the premises, the lien in principle lapses, except where they are removed without the landlord’s knowledge or against the landlord’s objection (§ 562a BGB).

Payments in the Crisis

Rent that the landlord received in the last three months before the filing or afterwards may in some circumstances be challenged by the insolvency administrator if the landlord knew of the insolvency or of the filing (§ 130 InsO). Current rent for current use can, however, as a so-called cash transaction (Bargeschäft), be challenged only under narrower conditions (§ 142 InsO). Instalment agreements on arrears, by contrast, should be reviewed carefully.

Practical Checklist for Landlords

  • Document arrears and payments received separately for the period before and after the filing.

  • File claims in the insolvency table on time after the opening of proceedings.

  • Demand current rent from the filing onwards; where new default occurs, review termination options.

  • Record the items brought onto the premises and object in writing to the removal of inventory.

  • Review rental security such as deposits or guarantees and whether they can be realised.

Conclusion

The tenant’s insolvency noticeably restricts the landlord’s rights, but leaves it room for action. Landlords who document early, classify claims correctly and assert their security preserve their position. Please do not hesitate to contact us if you have any questions.

Status: 18 October 2026

NIETZER Rechtsanwälte · Attorneys at Law (USA) · Heilbronn · www.unternehmensrecht.com

This article is for general information purposes and does not replace legal advice in an individual case.

bottom of page