Packaging Shape as a Trade Mark: What Matters Before Launch
Shape marks and packaging design: how manufacturers avoid trade mark infringement and protect their own designs
According to media reports, a well-known confectionery manufacturer is in dispute before a higher regional court (Oberlandesgericht) in southern Germany with a small food producer over the shape of a package. The regional court (Landgericht) had dismissed the claim. In the appeal hearing, the panel is reported to have indicated provisionally that it considers a likelihood of confusion to be plausible. A decision is still pending. The case shows that not only names and logos, but also packaging shapes can be protected as trade marks.
A Shape Can Also Be a Trade Mark
Under § 3 Abs. 1 Markengesetz (MarkenG), all signs capable of distinguishing the goods of one undertaking from those of other undertakings can be protected as trade marks. The statute expressly includes three-dimensional designs, including the shape of goods or their packaging. This is known as a shape mark (Formmarke).
However, signs are excluded from protection if they consist exclusively of a shape that results from the nature of the goods themselves, that is necessary to obtain a technical result, or that gives substantial value to the goods (§ 3 Abs. 2 MarkenG). Whether a shape gives substantial value to the goods is assessed by the courts on the basis of objective indicators, such as the category of goods, an artistic value, a clear departure from customary shapes in the sector, a significant price difference, or marketing that mainly emphasises aesthetics (CJEU, judgment of 18.09.2014 – C-205/13).
Many simple shapes are inherently not distinctive, meaning that buyers do not see in them an indication of a particular manufacturer. They can nevertheless be registered if they have become established, through use, as an indication of origin among the relevant public (§ 8 Abs. 3 MarkenG). The grounds for exclusion under § 3 Abs. 2 MarkenG cannot be overcome in this way.
When Is There an Infringement?
Under § 14 Abs. 2 Nr. 2 MarkenG, a trade mark is infringed if a third party, without consent, uses in the course of trade an identical or similar sign for identical or similar goods and a likelihood of confusion arises as a result. What matters is the interplay of factors: the similarity of the designs, the proximity of the products, and how well known and memorable the earlier mark is (its distinctiveness, Kennzeichnungskraft). A separate product name or logo on the packaging does not automatically rule out a likelihood of confusion.
For marks with a reputation in Germany, protection goes further: it is also prohibited to take unfair advantage of, or to impair, their distinctiveness or repute without due cause – irrespective of whether the goods are similar (§ 14 Abs. 2 Nr. 3 MarkenG).
The case that prompted this article suggests how differently courts can assess the same questions: whether two different snack products are “similar goods” and how similar two packages appear. There is a genuine litigation risk for both sides.
What Is at Stake in a Dispute
The proprietor of the mark can demand an injunction (§ 14 Abs. 5 MarkenG) and, where there is fault, damages, which can be calculated, among other methods, on the basis of a reasonable licence fee or the infringer’s profits (§ 14 Abs. 6 MarkenG). In addition there are claims for recall, removal from the channels of commerce and destruction of the goods (§ 18 MarkenG), unless this is disproportionate, as well as warning-letter and litigation costs. For a young company, such a dispute can affect the entire product line.
Practical Checklist for Companies
Before launch, have not only the name but also the packaging shape and design searched against earlier marks; shape marks and figurative marks require a specialist image search.
Deliberately keep a distance from well-known designs in your own sector.
Document design decisions and the reasons for them.
Register your own distinctive packaging early as a trade mark or design; for a design, novelty is a requirement.
If you receive a warning letter, observe the deadlines and do not sign a cease-and-desist undertaking without having it reviewed.
If you want to enforce rights yourself, weigh the litigation risk and public impact soberly in advance.
Conclusion
Packaging is more than marketing: it can infringe third-party trade mark rights or be eligible for protection itself. A search before the market launch usually costs considerably less than a lawsuit or a recall. Please do not hesitate to contact us if you have any questions.
Status: 17 October 2026
NIETZER Rechtsanwälte · Attorneys at Law (USA) · Heilbronn · www.unternehmensrecht.com
This article is for general information purposes and does not replace legal advice in an individual case.
