Trade Secrets: Protected Only If You Protect Them
Know-how protection and espionage: what confidentiality measures the Trade Secrets Act requires of companies
Media reports of alleged espionage targeting the top management of a large technology group have attracted a great deal of attention in recent days. Such cases show that anyone who wants to obtain confidential information often starts with people, not with technology. For mid-sized companies this raises a practical question: what must they do for their know-how to be legally protected at all?
No protection without your own measures
The Trade Secrets Act (Geschäftsgeheimnisgesetz, GeschGehG) does not protect every piece of confidential information. Under § 2 no. 1 GeschGehG, a trade secret requires, among other things, that the information is neither generally known nor readily accessible, therefore has commercial value and – according to letter b – is the subject of confidentiality measures that are reasonable under the circumstances, taken by its lawful holder (own translation). The Act thus requires active steps. Where such measures are lacking, there is legally no trade secret – even if the information is very valuable to the company.
What “reasonable” means
The Act does not define the term exhaustively. The circumstances are decisive: the value of the information, the size of the company, the usual security standards in the sector. The Stuttgart Higher Regional Court (OLG) has formulated a minimum standard (judgment of 19.11.2020 – 2 U 575/19): information may only reach persons who need it for their task and who are bound to secrecy. This is known as the “need-to-know principle”.
How important documentation is is shown by a decision of the Federal Labour Court (judgment of 17.10.2024 – 8 AZR 172/23). There, a company was unable to prove that it had taken reasonable confidentiality measures. Specific confidentiality clauses and a control system were missing, and the statements on IT security remained general. There was therefore no trade secret, and the claim for an injunction failed. The burden of proof for the protective measures lies with the company.
Caution with blanket confidentiality clauses
The same judgment also concerns employment contracts. The Federal Labour Court held a pre-formulated clause that obliges employees, without time limit after the end of the contract, to keep all internal matters confidential (a so-called catch-all clause) to be invalid because it unreasonably disadvantages the employee (§ 307 para. 1 sentence 1 BGB, German Civil Code). It would be tantamount to a post-contractual non-compete without compensation (Karenzentschädigung). In our assessment, clauses that name specific information are safer. Many older model contracts should therefore be reviewed.
What protection delivers
Where the requirements are met, § 4 GeschGehG prohibits, among other things, unauthorised access to, or unauthorised copying of, documents and files containing the secret. The holder can demand removal and injunctive relief, the latter already where an infringement is threatened for the first time (§ 6 GeschGehG); where the infringer is at fault, it is liable in damages (§ 10 GeschGehG). Certain infringements are also criminal offences (§ 23 GeschGehG); the range of penalties increases, among other things, where the offender knows that the secret is to be used abroad.
Practical checklist for companies
Identify critical know-how and classify it by need for protection.
Restrict access in line with the need-to-know principle, secure it technically and log it.
Draft confidentiality clauses in employment and managing director contracts specifically; replace catch-all clauses.
Conclude non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) with suppliers, customers and advisers.
Train employees and managers on social engineering (targeted manipulation of people) and targeted recruitment approaches.
On departure, demand the return of documents and devices and block access.
Document all measures in writing so that they can be proved in a dispute.
Conclusion
Trade secret protection does not begin in court but with a documented protection concept. Where the proof is missing, the claim is often missing too in a dispute. Please contact us if you have any questions.
As of: 10.11.2026
NIETZER Rechtsanwälte · Attorneys at Law (USA) · Heilbronn · www.unternehmensrecht.com
This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace legal advice in an individual case.
